This guide is part of the historical sexual offence allegations section.
What Is a Historical Sexual Offence Allegation?
A historical sexual offence allegation is one made about events that took place years, sometimes decades, before the complaint is made to Gardaí. There is no time limit on prosecuting sexual offences in Ireland. A person can be charged today with an offence said to have been committed in the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s, or any time since. Sexual offences are not subject to a statute of limitations the way some other offences are.
Historical allegations have become more common in Ireland since the late 1990s. The Ferns Report, the Ryan Report, and the Murphy Report changed public awareness of historical abuse. The Gardaí investigate historical allegations seriously. The Director of Public Prosecutions decides whether to prosecute based on the evidence available, regardless of the age of the allegation.
How Will Gardaí Usually Make First Contact?
First contact is typically by telephone or in person. A Garda will call you and ask you to attend a Garda station for an interview. The wording is usually polite and casual. You may be told that the Gardaí want to clear something up, or that they want to hear your side of the story, or that someone has made a complaint and they need to speak with you.
Some people are contacted at home, at work, or in front of family members. Some are contacted by a Garda they know personally. None of this changes what you should do. The contact itself is the moment to take legal advice.
Why You Should Not Attend the Interview Without a Solicitor
Attending a Garda interview about a historical sexual offence without specialist legal advice is one of the most damaging things you can do. The Gardaí are not your friends in this conversation. The interview is recorded. Anything you say can be used in evidence. Anything you do not say may also be used, in the form of inferences from silence under sections 18 and 19 of the Criminal Justice Act 1984 as amended, in certain narrow circumstances.
Historical allegations create particular risks for the accused. Memory of events from decades ago is unreliable. Witnesses may have died. Records may have been destroyed. Locations may have changed. A person trying to answer questions about events from 30 years ago is at a serious disadvantage. A specialist solicitor advises on what to say, what not to say, and when to invoke the right to silence.
Your Legal Rights When Gardaí Contact You
You have constitutional and statutory rights from the moment Gardaí make contact with you about an allegation. These rights are not contingent on you being charged. They apply during voluntary attendance, during arrest, and during detention.
-
Right to consult a solicitor
The right to consult a solicitor before and during interview, under the Custody Regulations 1987 and the Code of Practice on Access to a Solicitor.
-
Right to silence
You are not obliged to answer questions or to give a statement, with limited exceptions.
-
Right to be informed of the allegation
You are entitled to be informed of the allegation against you in sufficient detail to take legal advice on it.
-
Right to be cautioned
You must be cautioned before any interview about an offence takes place.
-
Right to have the interview recorded
Under the Criminal Justice Act 1984 (Electronic Recording of Interviews) Regulations 1997.
-
Right to medical attention and notification
The right to medical attention if needed, and the right to inform a person of your detention if you are arrested.
Voluntary Attendance Versus Arrest
Gardaí may invite you to attend the station as a volunteer. This means you are not under arrest, you are free to leave, and you may decline to answer questions. Voluntary attendance is presented as informal but the interview itself is anything but informal. The recording, the caution, and the evidential weight of what you say are identical to an interview after arrest.
If you decline voluntary attendance or leave during a voluntary interview, the Gardaí may decide to arrest you. Arrest gives them the power to detain you for questioning. The same rights apply. You should not attend voluntarily without first speaking to a solicitor and you should not stay in a voluntary interview that has begun without a solicitor present.
Prejudicial Delay: A Key Defence in Historical Cases
Where there has been a long delay between the alleged offence and the complaint or charge, the defence of prejudicial delay may apply. The Supreme Court has recognised that long delay can prejudice the right of the accused to a fair trial under Article 38.1 of the Constitution. Cases such as PM v DPP [2006] IESC 22 and SH v DPP [2006] 3 IR 575 set out the framework. Where the delay is so significant that the accused cannot fairly defend the allegation, an application can be made to prohibit the prosecution.
A successful prejudicial delay application requires evidence of specific prejudice. Loss of witnesses, loss of records, loss of memory in a way that prevents the defendant from challenging the allegation, and unfairness in the trial process can all support such an application. This is a specialist area. The application is usually made by way of judicial review to the High Court.
How a Specialist Sexual Offence Solicitor Defends a Historical Allegation
-
Garda Interview Strategy
The first step is the Garda interview, where the right to silence is usually exercised in full pending review of the allegation. No interview is attended without specialist advice in place.
-
Disclosure Examination
Once the DPP has the file, the solicitor obtains full disclosure and examines every piece of evidence, identifying inconsistencies, gaps, and defence opportunities.
-
Defence Identification
Complete denial, alibi, inconsistency in the complainant's account, prejudicial delay, contamination of evidence by media coverage or contact with other complainants - all are assessed and developed.
-
Full Trial Preparation
Witness preparation, character references, expert evidence on memory and the effect of time on testimony, and forensic examination of the original complaint are all part of a properly mounted defence.
What Happens After You Give Legal Advice and the Interview Takes Place
After interview, the Gardaí compile an investigation file. The file is sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions, who decides whether there is sufficient evidence and whether a prosecution is in the public interest. The DPP can take many months to decide on a sexual offence file. During this time, your solicitor liaises with the Garda investigator and prepares for the possibility of charge.
If charged, the case proceeds in the District Court for the initial appearance and is then sent forward to the Circuit Court or, in the case of rape and aggravated sexual assault, to the Central Criminal Court. The Book of Evidence is served. A trial date is set, often a year or more after charge. Throughout this process the accused is entitled to bail in most cases, although bail conditions in sexual offence cases are often strict.
Who Should You Call?
You should call a solicitor with specific, current experience in defending sexual offences. A general criminal defence solicitor is not the same thing as a specialist sexual offence defence solicitor. Sexual offence trials have their own procedural rules, their own evidential considerations, and their own sentencing framework. The Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 2017, the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 2006, the Criminal Law (Rape) Act 1981 as amended in 1990, and the Sex Offenders Act 2001 all have specific provisions that apply only to sexual offences.
Daniel Kreith Solicitors is a specialist sexual offence defence practice based in Limerick and serving the whole of Ireland. Daniel attends Garda stations 24 hours a day, seven days a week. The first call is free and confidential.
How Daniel Kreith Solicitors Can Help
If you have been contacted by Gardaí about a historical sexual offence allegation, contact Daniel Kreith Solicitors on 086 076 2191. Daniel will speak with you confidentially, advise you on the immediate steps, and attend the Garda station with you if an interview is to take place. Specialist representation from the first contact gives you the best chance of a fair process and a good outcome.
Speak to a Specialist Solicitor Today
Daniel Kreith & Company Solicitors provide confidential, specialist criminal defence for individuals facing sexual offence allegations across Ireland. Contact us to ensure your rights are protected.